I guess I'm saying I'd like to see at least mandatory deductions in P/E for messy programs period. Some skaters should always get huge S/S scores I get that. But it doesn't mean they should always be getting high P/E marks. This would level the field.
If one fall doesn't really affect a performance, then the P/E mark doesn't necessarily need to come down. But I do agree that judges tend to hold up this component in particular when the big names have their meltdowns.