Wednesday, November 10

Skate America Preview Part II: The Men

The Men
Maybe it's just me, but the men became my favorite discipline starting sometime last season and it has definitely continued into this season. The first two Grand Prix stops in particular featured some amazing skating, and I'm looking forward to seeing more of the same here. Current World Champion and Olympic Bronze Medalist Daisuke Takahashi leads the way, while last years Grand Prix Final silver medalist Nobunari Oda follows close behind. Adam Rippon looks to improve upon his bronze medal at Skate Canada, and several other skaters have a chance to sneak on to the podium.


En route to easily winning the NHK Trophy, Daisuke landed a clean quad toe loop in the free skate. However, both programs weren't without fault, and he is going to have to step up his game against more serious competition here. Looking at the final competition scores for Takahashi, Oda, and Rippon from their first events, there is only a three point difference between them (score-dragging issues aside). While I'm not blown away by either of his programs this season, I think they have enough flair and audience involvement that he could bring the house down in Portland if he is on his game.

Nobu won the short program at Skate Canada, but finished second overall after a fall on the triple Axel in the free skate. His problem during the last few seasons has been that he doesn't skate with much emotion, and his new programs come across as cold and uninteresting. He also had small issues with his spins in Kingston, losing points on almost every one of those elements. What Oda does have working for him are some of the most gorgeous basics and jumps in the world, if not the best on the latter. He includes steps in and out of most of them, and his landing position with such a deep knee bend is amazing. If he can relax a little bit and try to engage himself in his programs, I think Nobu can give his country mate a run for his money this week.

If you read enough of my blog, you know I went back and scored Skate Canada myself, and would have placed Adam first. He had a near-clean competition there, aside from a step-out of a triple Axel in the free skate. While he doesn't have the overall quality of basic skating or speed that the two Japanese men do, he fills his programs with transitions and really listens to the music. I think his free skate, in particular, can be magical if it is skated well this time around. We also need to remember that earlier this season, Rippon beat Takahashi at the Japan Open team competition, and I see him being a threat for the top once again this week. He's going to need at least second place to have a good shot at qualifying for the Grand Prix Final.

Other contenders
Kevin Van der Perren has flashes of brilliance all throughout each season he competes, so he can never be counted out. He had a disappointing short program in Japan, but climbed back to finish fifth in the free skate. I've always questioned his high scores for components, but at least he has made a small effort to address the problem this year.
Shawn Sawyer found himself in the top three after the short program at NHK, but too many mistakes in the free skate dropped him to fifth overall. He looks closer than ever to landing the triple Axel cleanly, and his long program to Alice in Wonderland is excellent. It should play well with the American audience.
Denis Ten has a new coach in Frank Carroll, and a new choreographer (for the short program) in Stephane Lambiel. Both programs fell flat at NHK, and the jumps really let him down in the free skate, where he dropped to last place overall. However, this is the skater that finished 6th in the long program at the World Championships two seasons ago-- as a 15 year old.
Armin Mahbanoozadeh had a great showing in the free skate at the Nebelhorn Trophy earlier this year, just missing out on the podium. Teammate Stephen Carriere has won two medals on the senior Grand Prix, and looks to start his comeback in Portland. He was a US-World Team member in 2008.
The "other" Daisuke, Daisuke Murakami, might have the lowest World Ranking of any of the men on the Grand Prix this season, but he had an impressive short program at the Finlandia Trophy last month.
Adrian Schultheiss of Sweden has opted for more traditional (by his standards) programs this season, but he finished a disappointing 10th at the NHK Trophy. He was 9th in the World last season, so he can't be counted out just yet.
Nan Song comes in relatively unknown, but he is the current World Junior Silver Medalist, and he was in second place following the short program at last years Four Continents Championships. This will be his international season debut.


Anonymous said...

Yeah, two days before the actual event the top 3 seem to be the first 3 men in your preview, Tony.

I hope SA panel scoring makes more sense than what their Canadian mates produced couple weeks ago. I really don't see Adam landing on his ass 4 times and grabbing gold as if nothing happened.

Anonymous said...

battle between Morozov's x-students. interensting!

Anonymous said...

Are you coming to watch the competition in person? I WIll be there from Japan and am crossing my fingers for Daisuke's winning !!!!

Tony said...

No, unfortunately Portland is on the other side of the United States, so I won't be there. Have fun!

Anonymous said...

i'm so happy to see Dai got his hair cut a little shorter, less curly. looks so much better. i like it.